Skip to content
BreakingBinding of Isaac AI music pulled after backlash

Binding of Isaac AI music pulled after backlash

Binding of Isaac AI music has been removed from the GTA-themed Daily Run. Nicalis patched PC, McMillen says he had no idea, and console fixes are on the way.

4 min read

The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ combat screenshot

In brief

AI summary
  1. Nicalis removed AI-generated music from The Binding of Isaac’s GTA-themed Daily Run after players discovered Suno metadata in the files.

  2. Creator Edmund McMillen said he was unaware of the AI music and promised to investigate its inclusion.

  3. The PC fix is live, while console patches are awaiting approval from Microsoft, Nintendo, and Sony.

Contents9 sections

The Binding of Isaac AI music has been pulled from the game after a player backlash. According to Nicalis' official X post on November 21, a new PC build removes the generated music files, with console patches to follow.

The trouble began when Repentance+ launched on consoles on November 19. The date was no accident: the update was timed to land on the same day as the worldwide launch of GTA 6. The Steam version also got a special GTA-themed Daily Run.

Official Steam announcement art for the Repentance+ November 19 update
Official art from Nicalis for the November 19 update (Source: Nicalis, Steam)

How was the Binding of Isaac AI music discovered?

Nicalis' November 19 Steam patch notes urged players to try that day's Daily Run for a crime-packed surprise. The mode came with GTA-style weapons and its own soundtrack.

A day later, Reddit user ShweetsStuff dug into the files. As Kotaku reported, the run shipped with 14 music files. Some carried metadata pointing to Suno, an AI music generator. On the other files that note had been scrubbed.

The music was only half the problem. Steam asks developers to disclose AI-generated content on the store page, and Repentance+ had no such notice. That rule has been a flashpoint before. In October, Tim Sweeney slammed the Steam AI disclosure as political.

Binding of Isaac AI music at a glance

  • November 19: Repentance+ hits consoles, Steam gets a GTA-themed Daily Run
  • November 20: Suno metadata is found in the music files on Reddit
  • November 21, 15:52 UTC: Edmund McMillen says he had no idea
  • November 21, 20:40 UTC: Nicalis ships a PC build that removes the music
  • Consoles: The patch is with Microsoft, Nintendo and Sony

What did Edmund McMillen and Nicalis say?

Series creator Edmund McMillen spoke first. In his November 21 post on X, he said he woke up to a mess. He had no idea the Daily Run used generated music, and he promised to find out how it happened and get it removed.

A few hours later, Nicalis pushed a new build. The publisher listed the removal of generated music files, a fix for a Larynx and Car Battery bug, and a PC patch that should already be live. Work on the netcode also continues. Nicalis has not explained how the music got into the game.

The GTA 6 launch date stunt was Nicalis' idea too. McMillen told Eurogamer that the publisher pitched it and he went along with it because it sounded funny. Repentance+ first arrived on PC in 2024 as a free update that added online co-op, and console players had been waiting a long time for it.

The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ dungeon room screenshot
Repentance+ has been on PC since 2024 and on consoles since November 19 (Source: Steam, Nicalis)

What does it mean for players?

On PC the fix is already here. Update the game and the AI tracks in the GTA-themed run are gone. Players on PS5, Xbox Series X|S and Switch 2 will have to wait for certification, and there is no date for that yet.

The Steam rating is still on the floor. IGN reported on November 21 that only 8 percent of recent Repentance+ reviews were positive. It is not the only review bomb this month. The GTA 6 Metacritic user score took a similar hit.

The pushback against AI in games keeps growing. Embark recently faced a backlash over AI casters in The Finals, and Valve said it is working on the AI slop problem on Steam. The Isaac case shows again why the disclosure rule matters.

Frequently asked questions

Has the AI music been removed from The Binding of Isaac?

Yes, on PC. Nicalis released a new build on the evening of November 21 that removes the generated music files. Console patches have been submitted to Microsoft, Nintendo and Sony and are awaiting approval.

Where was the AI-generated music used?

It was used in the special GTA-themed Daily Run added with the November 19 update. There are no claims of AI music elsewhere in the game.

Did Edmund McMillen know about the AI music?

No. McMillen wrote on X on November 21 that he had no idea the Daily Run featured generated music and that he was looking into how it happened.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Questions answered in this article

Sources

External links cited in this article

  1. 01According to Nicalis' official X post on November 21x.com (opens in a new tab)
  2. 02Nicalis, Steamstore.steampowered.com (opens in a new tab)
  3. 03As Kotaku reportedkotaku.com (opens in a new tab)
  4. 04In his November 21 post on Xx.com (opens in a new tab)
  5. 05Steam, Nicalisstore.steampowered.com (opens in a new tab)
  6. 06IGN reported on November 21ign.com (opens in a new tab)

Newsletter

The week's biggest gaming news, every Friday morning

One email every Friday: the week's most-read stories and what's new. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Author

FireGhost

@alikemal1,407 articles

LoL, TFT ve VALORANT sever bir oyun sever ve oyuncu. Mobil platformlarda ise tam bir Clash of clans hastası.

Related articles

All PC

Comments